| Name |
Years as Pastor |
| John Marchisio |
1917 – 1926 |
| Egisto Tozzi |
1926 – 1930 |
| Charles P. Hardemann |
1930 – 1933 |
| Morris Redner |
1933 – 1941 |
| Martin J. O’Fahey |
1941 – 1944 |
| Denis J. Glennon |
1944 – 1947 |
| Philip F. Ryan |
1947 – 1951 |
| Thomas P. Garrigan |
1951 – 1952 |
| John J. Curtin |
1952 – 1955 |
| Raymond F. Halker, C.PP.S. |
1955 – 1958 |
| Peter A. Brickner, C.PP.S. |
1958 – 1965 |
| Aloys G. Selhorst, C.PP.S. |
1965 – 1967 |
| Fr. Ganger, C.PP.S |
|
| Fr. Vollmer, C.PP.S. |
|
| Fr. Delaney, C.PP.S. |
|
| Fr. Beuth, C.PP.S. |
|
| Fr. Steffas, C.PP.S. |
|
| Lawrence J. McGovern, S.T.L. |
1993 – 2000 |
| Richard E. Morse, OSFS |
2000 - 2007 |
| Fr. J. Patrick Walker |
2007 - Present |
|
